In response to the practices of the Neocathecumenal Way in Las Cruces, NM

And the opening of the Redemptoris Mater Seminary affiliated with the NCW

For the Good of Our Diocese

A respectful clarification-Our response to the letter from Deacon Winder

Dear Deacon Jim,

Thank you for sharing your concerns and for your evident love for the Diocese of Las Cruces. We all desire what is best for the Church, for our Bishop, for our priests, and for the faithful entrusted to their care.

However, some statements in your message do not fully reflect the situation that many clergy and laity have witnessed and experienced over the past several years.

First, the concerns raised are not simply about whether Bishop Peter “involves priests enough in decision making.” The issues brought forward by priests and many members of the faithful involve broader matters of pastoral governance, financial transparency, the introduction and preferential promotion of the Neocatechumenal Way, concerns regarding the formation of diocesan seminarians at Saint Joseph Seminary, liturgical practices that have caused confusion in parishes, and the treatment of clergy and laity who have respectfully raised questions.

Second, it is not accurate to suggest that only “three priests” have concerns. Many priests, religious, and lay faithful across the Diocese have expressed serious concerns, though not all feel free to speak openly for fear of retaliation. Likewise, over 1,200 faithful signed petitions asking for dialogue and clarity regarding these matters.

Third, regarding the apostolic visitation, it is our understanding that testimonies were gathered from multiple individuals, including clergy and the laity, and that the concerns raised were substantial enough to warrant a serious review by the competent authorities in Rome.

Fourth, statements regarding diocesan finances remain a matter of concern precisely because questions of transparency have not been clearly addressed. In addition, the civil litigation involving the diocesan whistleblower has only increased the faithful's desire for clarity and accountability.

No one seeks to do injustice to Bishop Peter, nor is this about personal attacks. The faithful who have spoken have done so because Canon Law itself recognizes not only the right but sometimes the duty of the faithful to make known their concerns for the good of the Church (cf. can. 212 §3).

Supporting a bishop should never require silence in the face of legitimate concerns. True communion in the Church rests on truth, charity, accountability, and pastoral care for all the faithful—not on fear, division, or the suppression of respectful questions.

We continue to pray for Bishop Peter, our priests and deacons, and for the healing and unity of our Diocese.

In Christ,

The Voice of the Laity

About Voice of the laity

MISSION STATEMENT

We, the "Voice of the Laity" of Las Cruces, NM, are dedicated to preserving the integrity and unity of the Catholic faith. Grounded in Sacred Scripture, Tradition, and the Magisterium, we advocate for the reverent celebration of the Holy Eucharist and vibrant parish life in line with Catholic liturgical and theological norms.

Through prayer, education, and collaboration, we strive to strengthen our Catholic identity, seek unity in Christ through the grace of the Holy Sacraments, and support our Clergy and laity. Together, we seek to amplify the voice of the Catholic laity within our community and beyond.

In response to the practices of the Neocathecumenal Way in Las Cruces, NM

“Truth is never defeated by error; it triumphs in time.”

For the Good of Our Diocese

A respectful clarification-Our response to the letter from Deacon Winder

Letter from Deacon Jim Winder

STAND WITH YOUR PARISH COMMUNITY!

About Voice of the laity

MISSION STATEMENT

pray and act without delay!

In response to the practices of the Neocathecumenal Way in Las Cruces, NM

“Truth is never defeated by error; it triumphs in time.”

For the Good of Our Diocese

A respectful clarification-Our response to the letter from Deacon Winder

Letter from Deacon Jim Winder

STAND WITH YOUR PARISH COMMUNITY!

About Voice of the laity

MISSION STATEMENT

pray and act without delay!

This website uses cookies.